Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What would you do??

who's talking here?

Katie Thomas 1
☆Felicia☆ 1
Krysti 1
Marie 4
~*Mrs. Butterfly*~ 3
Rhonda P 1
onceacop 1
TruthSeeker 1
ItsMe 2
~~Brandi~~ 2
*Loved* 1
Joseph 1
Heather D. 15
RYAN 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Alright, here's the deal. I sold a portable dvd player like 2 weeks ago. It worked just fine the day before I sold it. It had been used regularly up until about a week before it was sold. No problems at ALL. I sold it. Now 2 weeks later this lady comes knocking at my door saying that it worked the first day and now it shuts off after the starting credits of movies. She claims that she has tried to email me about it. I haven't gotten ANY email from her since I sold it to her. I even checked my bulk mail. I don't mind giving her money back if it doesn't work. My only thing is that she waited 2 weeks to tell me, after she said it didn't work right after the first day. (and I tried it out the day before she bought it to double check, and it worked great). I gave her my address to pick it up, ( I wouldn't have done that if I was selling her faulty equipment.) I talked to my husband about it and he says not to refund the money because she waited 2 weeks to tell me something was wrong with it. Like he said, how do we know that she didn't drop it, her kids do something to it, and now wants to get her money back? Another issue I have, is that I sold it to her for almost $15 cheaper than I had it listed because she was buying more than one thing. So I combined everything and sold it all to her for $41, where as if she had bought everything at the listed price she would have owed $55. So if I were to refund her, how much do I give her back? What would any of you all do in this situation?? 

Krysti --- 18 years ago -

Heck no, dont give her the money back. If there really was a problem, she would have emailed you before now. Maybe this person messed it up herself and just want to blaim you. Don't give her a dime. 

~~Brandi~~ --- 18 years ago -

Sounds like someone needing money back because they spent money and they shouldn't have. I wouldn't even worry about it. It is a yard sale site, you dont' sell stuff with warranties, lol 

RYAN --- 18 years ago -

tell her to go somewhere and that there is no proof that she didnt do it so she is screwed... she can get it fixed herself 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Thats what what husband told me. I mean I double checked it. It worked great right before she bought it. The only thing wrong with it was the remote was lost. But still functioned just fine without it. I mean I do feel bad that it isn't working right for her and she claims that she's emailed me several times. But I swear I haven't gotten any emails from her. Heck, if I had gotten her emails, and was avoiding her, I wouldn't have answered my door when she knocked. But I don't want to give the money back if someone messed it up after she bought it. That's not my problem. I mean, I'm not walmart..lol. 

Katie Thomas --- 18 years ago -

You're under no obligation to refund the money in my opinion...sounds weird that she waited 2 weeks to complain to you about it. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

lol... you soound like my husband ryan. 

~*Mrs. Butterfly*~ --- 18 years ago -

well i bought a dvd player from sumone off here who was askin 10 for it but took 5 bucks for it and came with remote she said it worked before i walked out the house. i got home next day i tried to play a movie and it worked alright but then it just cut off like u said she said. and i didnt even want to deal with all the bs of askin to return it even though it was 5 bucks. so i just gave it to sumone who might know how to fix it free... so its been 2 weeks i wouldnt give the money back either or to get just have it dropped i would give her half back of what she paid for it 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Yeah thats what I was thinking. I don't sell broken things. Ask Johanna, she bought my stereo. 2 weeks is a long time to wait.. 

~~Brandi~~ --- 18 years ago -

sounds like something happened in the 2 weeks that she had it, oh well, sucks for her!!! if they worked when you sold them then that is all you have to worry about. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Thanks Mary. I would gladly give her money back if it was my fault, but waiting 2 weeks, I just don't know. 

~*Mrs. Butterfly*~ --- 18 years ago -

yeah, i purchased a washer and dryer while back and the dryer they said worked great paid 150 for them both together. washer worked dryer didnt. i emailed that day and had no number adn she moved so i couldnt go to her house she wouldnt return my emails so i got screwed out of 75 so i think in that case i should of got my money back but in ur case took her 2 weeks to come bout it and there is no proof. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Yes you should have gotten your money back on that deal. Especially seeing as you tried to notify them THAT SAME DAY. This lady emailed me that day to ask about the remote, but that was all. Nothing from her since, until today. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Thank you all for the input. I just didn't want to tell her no she can't have money back and them seem like the bad guy. And I also didn't want to give it back just because she may have messed it up too. 

ItsMe --- 18 years ago -

I wouldnt refund her either. I can understand maybe if she took it home and said it didnt work the same day maybe even the next day but if they wait any longer than that there is no telling what they could have done to it to cause it to break. Just a piece of advice..next time you sell a electronic plug it in and let them see it works before they leave, that way if they try it again you wont feel bad about saying no refund (hopefully they wont ask for one knowing it worked when they left your place). I did this to all the stuff I sell, I make sure they come in and see it working first. I am sorry for the rest of you that got things that didnt work properly. I have been there myself, but the owner of the item wasnt home so instead of coming back I just took it from the person who happened to be at the house. It didnt work properly either, just glad I didnt spend alot on it. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

you better believe I will make it a point to show thats working BEFORE they leave with it. This is just crap. I thank all of you for the advise. I feel a little better about telling her no refund. 

TruthSeeker --- 18 years ago -

to me once some one buys an item its all theirs its sold as is and eveyrone should check out stuff before they buy it and walk out some ones door.i wouldnt refund more so two weeks is retarded.she's full of crap 

~*Mrs. Butterfly*~ --- 18 years ago -

i know with the dryer my husband would of tried to make sure it worked, but they were "moving" had everything packed and the washer adn dryer undone moved to a place not near a dryer plug would be and so hubby asked r u sure nothing wrong with it and lady was like its perfect we just moving into a place that has them already. then her neighbor who posted the things on the site i emailed her and she said that she talked with the lady who was selling them and that it needed a new belt thats all. i had sumone come look at it and he told me it needed a whole new heating element or motor or sumthing i dont rememeber now but yea so bs and should of got my money back lol. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

With the dryer, I completely understand. I would have wanted my money back too. Everything is usually sold as is. And I KNOW that the dvd player worked at time of purchase. 

onceacop --- 18 years ago -

I have to agree with everyone eles on the player . she should have checked it out the day of the sale .. but two weeks later not !! How do you know for sure that someone at thier house didnt do something.. and its not like it was new with a warrenty ... this is a yard sale if the item worked when it left your house thats all it needed to do I always make it a point to show that its in running order this way they cant say it was broke before they got it ,,, 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

The thing that gets me is that she even said that it worked after she got it home. 

ItsMe --- 18 years ago -

Yeah it sounds like someone wants their money back cause 1-they are broke and need the cash or 2-they found something else they wanted and maybe 3-they broke it but thought to blame you so that they are not at a loss 

*Loved* --- 18 years ago -

yeah either something happened, or she is having buyer's remorse and needs the $ back maybe. 2 weeks is WAY too ling. if she wasn't getting any reply from emaile (suypposedly) then why didn't she come leave you a note at home..i mean since she knows where you live..or at least find you on cys? sounds fishy...next day ok, but 2 weeks? no! even she said it worked the first day..so how are you supposed to know unless you palyed it for hours to test it... 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

im glad that im not the only one that thinks something is odd about her waiting 2 weeks to say something. thanks everyone. i feel a lot better about calling and telling her i cant refund it. 

☆Felicia☆ --- 18 years ago -

YEA I AGREE.. DO NO REFUND HER.. SHE SHOULD HAVE TOLD YOU IT DIDNT WORK THAT SAME DAY NOT TWO WEEKS LATER.. SHE PROLLY BROKE IT LIKE YOU SAID AND NOW WANTS HER MONEY BACK.. LOL PEOPLE. 

Marie --- 18 years ago -

Ok here is the deal...when I bought it she said if there was anything wrong with it just let her know and she would take it back. Now It is a portable DVD player and yes it works while it is plugged in but it will not hold a charge. Whick is what I told her I never said it was broken there is nothing wrong with it as that is concerned. But what good is a portable dvd player that u cant take anywhere? I have been trying to email her but yahoo has been messing up big time on me. I have had several people not getting my emails as well as me not recieving theirs. So yeah I went to her house. And she was very nice and I was nice and she said she had no problem giving me my money back. I bought the thing so I could have it for my kids in the car but it wont even play with the car charger. So now what would u do if u were me? And yeah i might have just taken the lose but why should i lose $40 and have nothing to show for it? Especially when she told me when i bought it that if there was anything wrong let her know. 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

Marie, How was it charged when you got it ( as you stated ) .And now will not hold a charge ? Again, Just trying to understand this whole thing. 

Marie --- 18 years ago -

And as far as it working the first day that was me binging it plugging it up and putting a movie in, yes the movie played fine so I thought "hey great". That was that until a few days later when I actually went to use it I plugged up to charge, next morning it has a green light full charge I put in a movie and the movie previews didnt even come on before it just shuts off. Plug it back in and it works. And as far as buyers remorse if i can get my money back then i am just going to turn around and buy another one. Anyone on here that has ever does business with me knows that I am a good person and I would never do anyone wrong. I just expect the same courtesy. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Marie, I was going to call you but since you were one here not to long ago, I'll just relay here. Yes when you bought it I told you that when you got it home if it didn't work to bring it back and I would refund you. But I didn't think that you would wait 2 weeks. That's a big long to wait. I also told you when you bought it that we hadn't used the charger to it in a long time. We kept it plugged in with the car charger or the wall plug. My husband also told me last night that brand new the actual battery would only last you 3 hours at most. The car charger worked great with the portable dvd player all the way up til I sold it to you. My husband and daughter used it often. ( my husband used it daily for the last 2 months we had it while he was on the road traveling.. he said it never gave him problems). After talking to him, he said no to a refund. Especially since you waited 2 weeks to let us know about it. If it was same day or even the next day or so it would have been different. Another thing, you gave me $41 for the portable dvd player, 2 picture frames, and a nativity figurine set. I had the picture frames listed for $4 and the dvd player listed for $55. I gave them all to you for $41, just how much am I to refund you if I were to give a refund?? I want to be nice and do the right thing, but as several people have brought up, you waited 2 weeks to notify me of the issue. CYS is also a yard sale site. Would you go to an actual yard sale, buy something, and then take it back 2 weeks later wanting your money back? I am sorry about the whole situation. And yes I told you I would refund you if it didn't work when you bought it, but I'm also not walmart or a big store that gives 30/90/or longer warranties. What's the proper warranty time for a yard sale item? I don't know. But as of right now, my husband is telling me not to refund you. I am sorry. 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

Also if it works fine plugged in, you may be able to get a new replacement battery for it for cheap. All in all you still got it cheaper than brand new. My husband payed $150 for it brand new 2 years ago. .. I'm sorry for all of this. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day