Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Folic Acid causes Autism??

who's talking here?

*maranda* 1
poppin~wheelies! 2
MamaJessica2 4
Hooah Wifey 1
Supervillain 3
JM_ 3
muffie 1
SECURITY! 1
*CU Drama Queen* 9
NoleFan 6
B's Mommy 3
karrie 1
Bambeeno82 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

B's Mommy --- 17 years ago -

did anyone hear about how the push for higher levels of folic acid coincide with the rise in autism? dr. humberg was telling me about this. i havent really looked into yet. i was just wondering if anyone else has? 

JM_ --- 17 years ago -

I haven't heard it 

JM_ --- 17 years ago -

Here's and entire chat about it http://www.mothering.com/discussions/showthread.php?t=531772 

B's Mommy --- 17 years ago -

i just checked it out. how weird. apparently the person who reported all of the data about vaccines admitted he falsified information. i never got into that craze, but this seems to make a little more sense. i'm really interested to find out more. 

Hooah Wifey --- 17 years ago -

I didn't know that... I never took any folic acid pills or went for that while preggo w my son. I didn't even know I was preggo until I was 12 weeks along. Try to take the prenatal vitamins and couldn't keep them down so I stop those too and stuff myself w pizza and brownies. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

First it was vaccines, now folic acid. I think its a bunch of BS and I wouldnt be surprised if it came out that Autism is a gene carried by the parents 

Supervillain --- 17 years ago -

That isn't possible in my case. I didn't take any prenatals because they made me sick and I don't really remember going out of my way to consume folic acid, despite the risk of spinal bifida. My reasoning was how many kids actually have spinal bifida? I wasn't overly convinced about the vaccine theory, either. I kept an open mind about it, though. If it was proven beyond a shadow of a doubt, I was prepared to be livid. But so far as I know, it hasn't. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

What I dont get is, Autism isnt a "new condition". The entire 3rd floor of my Junior High School was designated as a school for autistic children. We all werent worried about vaccines, vitamins and folic acid causing it then, so why now? And I remember when I was in school (not sure if its like this now), but, you couldnt be enrolled unless you where up to date on vaccine's. Same vaccine's that are around now and the majority of us where just fine. Our mothers took the pre natal and folic acid pills during pregnancy also. So, wouldnt that lead to believe that its NOT one of these causes, or, there would be a hell of a lot more cases of Autism? Have they done any gene or internal reasoning testing towards might what be the cause for Autism? 

*maranda* --- 17 years ago -

i actually had a doctor imply that my son was autistic because i took paxil in my first trimester, and he was the the guy who prescribed it. i went to another doctor and she said he was a quack. so who knows. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

According to the Autism society of America, there are conducting genetic testing to see if maybe is a malformation in genes or a trigger in the brain that may set it off. And we have a friend, had twins. Fed them the same, took the same vitamins and folic acid, same vaccine's at the same time, yet only one child was diagnosed with Autism. 

Supervillain --- 17 years ago -

What I dont get is, Autism isnt a "new condition". There was a recent boom of autism cases. If I'm not mistaken, it reached epidemic proportions. Like one in every 100 births? Don't quote me, but that seems about right to me. 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

Autism has been around for 100's of years. Only people used to call it being retarded and they used to put Autistic people away in homes. Autism is not a new condition, it just seems like it because people are actually studying it now and realizing all the different levels of Autism there are. Oh and the lack of folic acid can cause birth defects of the heart, urinary tract, and facial structure (cleft pallet), anemia in the mother, placental abruption, low birth weight, and even downs syndrome. 

poppin~wheelies! --- 17 years ago -

I agree with amber, in my son's case there were no prenatals because of the ill effects. I was on brethine to stop preterm labor at 14 weeks. so from 14 to 37 weeks I took that and it is known to cause autism. I do find it funny that everyone now has all this news on it because when my son started having his symptoms no one knew what it was. It is only in the last 3 years that it has really come to be known well and that is why they say there has been a significant rise in it. It has always been this high, no one just knew what it was. With my son he had a clubbed foot so they thought it was cerebral palsy but finally when he was 9 we got the accurate diagnosis. ABA therapy has gotten his diagnosis upgraded from full autism to aspergers. If you were to meet him you would never know he had it. 

poppin~wheelies! --- 17 years ago -

yeah I also agree with jessica, when my son was 2 they told me to lock him away in a home. I told them to kiss my a$$ and did the aba therapy myself and now he is better! 

NoleFan --- 17 years ago -

There was a recent boom of autism cases. If I'm not mistaken, it reached epidemic proportions. Like one in every 100 births? Don't quote me, but that seems about right to me. it is either 1 in 100 or 1 in 150 and it is def. on the rise but what you have to understand is that there is a broad spectrum of Autism and some docs maybe diagnosing kids now on the lower spectrum more so than they did before. I don't know, it's a thought. 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

I think the rise is due to the discovery that Autism is a spectrum disorder. Before the 1990's Autism was mostly diagnosed by an extreme desire to be alone and have things the same. That was the guideline. So basically children who couldn't speak and were very low functioning were diagnosed. Then they created the interview for Autism and more kids started fitting into that category. Then they realized there was a large spectrum and different levels of Autism were being diagnosed. Back in the 40's the man that named Autism said it was caused by cold and impersonal parenting. Now of course we are finding it is an underlying genetic abnormality and often triggered by an outside source. Some people believe that is vaccines, now apparently they believe it is folic acid too. I would never avoid taking folic acid though, because the risks of not taking it outweigh the risks of autism. Thats the same reason I get my kids vaccinated. Autism is a better alternative than watching my children die a painful death from Measles or another freaky disease. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

I just wonder though, if its triggered by an outside source, how could only one of two twins be triggered. They carry the same DNA, are fed and cared for the same, vaccinated the same, yet only one child is Autistic? 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

I just wonder though, if its triggered by an outside source, how could only one of two twins be triggered. They carry the same DNA, are fed and cared for the same, vaccinated the same, yet only one child is Autistic? idk one possibility I can think of right off hand is that, if vaccines do infact trigger Austisim, one twin may have had a vaccine with a higher level of toxicity than the other. No two vaccines are exactly the same. Also one vaccine could have been outdated or had something else wrong with it. Thats all I can think of off the bat. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

I always thought one twin might have been born w/a genetic mutation while the other wasnt. Im also a firm believer that Autism is a lot like Schizophrenia, its just something that may have always been there, but theres an internal trigger 

MamaJessica2 --- 17 years ago -

Actually they have linked Schizophrenia to the lack of folic acid to the fetus. lol But as for the twin thing, I just googled and it seems that just being a twin could be the trigger. "This means that environmental factors in the womb, placental development, or even the experience of being raised with a same-age sibling could have some triggering effect for autism." 

NoleFan --- 17 years ago -

I always thought one twin might have been born w/a genetic mutation while the other wasnt. Im also a firm believer that Autism is a lot like Schizophrenia, its just something that may have always been there, but theres an internal trigger There can be one twin who has schizophrenia and one not as i believe is the case with autism. Yeah I dont know haven't read twin studies regarding autism but now i probably will. bc it would be interesting 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

But as for the twin thing, I just googled and it seems that just being a twin could be the trigger. "This means that environmental factors in the womb, placental development, or even the experience of being raised with a same-age sibling could have some triggering effect for autism." You know I never thought of that lol 

NoleFan --- 17 years ago -

I think the rise is due to the discovery that Autism is a spectrum disorder. Before the 1990's Autism was mostly diagnosed by an extreme desire to be alone and have things the same. That was the guideline. So basically children who couldn't speak and were very low functioning were diagnosed. Then they created the interview for Autism and more kids started fitting into that category. Then they realized there was a large spectrum and different levels of Autism were being diagnosed. That is what I was saying and a lot of the children are getting labled as autistic when in fact they probably are not. That is what I think. I mean they think bc a child likes to play alone and doesn't say a lot of words by 2 he may be autisitc my son does that. They gave me their little autism survey for my boy twin, but not my girl at well baby which i thought was odd i know it is higher in boys but why wouldn't they give it for her also? Mabe the docs are the one thinking all of these boys are sutistic. And by saying autistic in this context I am talking about on the lower end of the spectrum 

NoleFan --- 17 years ago -

You know I never thought of that lol I kinda think that is why my son is what i would call an introvert bc his sister has always been the opposite and she had colic so he had to just sit there and listen to her cry for three months straight and of course she got more attention and holding and stuff bc I was tring to calm her down and i was usually by myself. so i think he just learned to cope with things early on by himself i dont know 

muffie --- 17 years ago -

morning ya'll... about the pills i was told that the folic acid decreased the chances of spinabifita greatly along with any health issues with the spine but never heard it was a increase in aut. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

I also think that doctors are wayyyyy to quick to toss out an Autism diagnosis. Like Char said, some kids are just introverts and would rather stay to themselves. Dosent mean anything is medically wrong with them. 

NoleFan --- 17 years ago -

I also think that doctors are wayyyyy to quick to toss out an Autism diagnosis. Like Char said, some kids are just introverts and would rather stay to themselves. Dosent mean anything is medically wrong with them Maybe when he gets to school and is placed in a different classroom he will be a totally different kid he will be like finally i dont have to be around her everyday LOL 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

Remember when we where younger we all had the "quiet" friend. Didnt talk much, stayed to himself, didnt learn quite on par but they where prob the coolest friend you ever had? Did we ever think that kid was Autistic? Nope. Usually they grow up to be one of the more productive adults out of their peers 

SECURITY! --- 17 years ago -

Usually they grow up to be one of the more productive adults out of their peers or end up slaughtering everyone in his house. 

NoleFan --- 17 years ago -

Remember when we where younger we all had the "quiet" friend Yeah that was me. I was quiet and I could entertain myself and had all kinds of clubs with only one member me Ok dont make fun but i did. I wouldn't say i am a productive adult at this point in time but i will be. I think, i hope anyways. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day