Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Democracy or communism

who's talking here?

Dianne 4
Rhonda P 3
ItsMe 1
Joseph 2
Heather D. 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Joseph --- 18 years ago -

just my thoughts has any noticed how much the u.s. has been adopting communist thinking. for example the imminent domain law. what this is is the gov. can come in and take your land and make u move if they feel your land is beneficial to everyone (and i mean them.). thats about as communist as it gets. Also the seat belt law. what gives any one the rite to decide your safty for you. for the populous as a whole, yes definatly. but to govern the safty of the individual is communist. they have no rite to govern what we do with ourselfs. (also applies to helmet law) third argument the new non smoking law. if i build a resturante up from the ground and i want to allow smoking what buisness is it of the goverment. if the smoke in my resturante bothers you go somewhere else. no body is forcing you to eat at that establishment. it is pure communisim. I say down with the communist laws and bring back democracy in this country especially in tn. you know since this country was founded on it!! God Bless Salute the Flag and give your input 

Joseph --- 18 years ago -

Also i wont argue for the seat belt and helmet law for those under 18. since the gov. says there not adults yet. but since there not adults should they really be allowed to drive a 2000lbs wrecking ball. just another thought 

Dianne --- 18 years ago -

Okay - the US has had emminent domain for a LONG time - way before communism. The difference between the US government and communism is that the US will pay you for the land at a fair market value. A communism government does not pay and will bury your body if you cause much of a ruckus about it. There are helmet and seat belt laws in pretty much every civilized country. I mean you might think it's YOUR life and YOUR body - but it's the state funded rescue services that have to be payed from government funds to scrape your body or head off the pavement. Also when you are laying in the hospital with tubes keeping you alive and you don't have insurance that will pay to keep you alive - it becomes the states problem and if you don't have a DNR then they could keep you alive for 20 years on their dime. Plus if you have SGLI - they will not pay your life insurance if are not wearing a helmet or seat belt. Smoking in restaurants - it's mainly there to protect children and non-smokers. I do believe that bars that do not allow anyone under 18 or 21 will allow smoking - such as the Sports bar next to the mall and Rebounds. I don't think that the United States of American is going any where near communism! If it was everyone would be working for the same rate, we would have military conscription,we would have no personal religion, no system of justice, or private enterprise. The US is very much a capitalistic society! I really don't understand your seat belt argument - it make no sense. So are you saying that the law is good for the masses but should not be enforced individually? One last thing - the US was not founded on democracy - but a Republic. In pledge it plainly states "I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which is stands....." 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

As for the seat belt issue. This does not always benefit you in saving your life. My husband's friend died over sea when his humvee over turned in a very shallow river and drowned due to his seat belt not being able to come loss. (He left behind a Wife and a Daughter) I have seen many accidents that if the seat belt was not there. They could have gotten to the person faster. How is it when I went on a field trip with my child this year there were NO seat belts on the bus? I do how ever agree that we are not TOTALLY a communist country, but we are slowly getting there. When our own government is starting to tell us how we are to raise our own children, who gives them the right to do this ,as we are the ones that pay their expensive until they are 18 still, it is surely not our government to do this and still have the right to tell us how to raise them. They have also started telling us what they feel is right for us to eat. they tell us about smoking in our car's that we pay for. If Smoking in places are for the safety of children (but again they don’t feel the need for safety of seat belts in School Bus) And when it come to bar's ,since that is limiting their liquor taxes ( they may lift this one ) As people are starting to see they can stay home or have a party at friend's houses and smoke in at their home and not pay the high cost of drinks in the bar. And still would have to stand outside in -35 deg weather. Do You still feel this is any better? Quoted : mean you might think it's YOUR life and YOUR body - but it's the state funded rescue services that have to be payed from government funds to scrape your body or head off the pavement. As for the state funding rescue services .I don’t know how it is in Tenn., but every other state I have ever lived in; you get a bill for the fire trucks and ambulance when they have to come to a scene to save your life. Quoted: The difference between the US government and communism is that the US will pay you for the land at a fair market value. A communism government does not pay and will bury your body if you cause much of a ruckus about it. I STRONGLY feel, if we give our government some time, they WILL add this to their laws, as they have changed some many laws over the years. What makes this any different? 

Heather D. --- 18 years ago -

If it's a law to wear a seat belt, than yes the school buses should have them. They claim that the buses are safe enough, that the children have just a great a chance at surviving in one with out the seat belts as they do in a car with them. I don't think so. I mean if a school bus flips, the kids are going to be bounced EVERYWHERE. If they are going to enforce seat belts in a car/truck/van/suv, they should enfore it on a bus. By the way, do the public city buses have seat belts??? I agree with you Rhonda, the government is starting to try and tell us how to raise our children. They tell us what they can and can't eat from birth. They tell us we can't spank (not beat, but spank) our children. We are told that we have to vacinate them (not that that is entirely bad, but we are told we have to). ETC ETC. They are our children and we are responsible for them until they are at least 18years old. Why are we being told when, why, and how to bring them up?? And yes in Tennessee, you are sent a bill if the fire trucks, ambulance, etc come to your rescue. So Diane, you might want to reconsider your statement there. WE are the ones who pay the bills if WE choose not to wear seat belts and helmets. NOT THE STATE. And if you don't have insurance, YOU/ME/WE still get the bill for those services. I know. My mom has insurance, medicare and private, and she still gets the bill whenever she has to be rushed to the hospital (for life threatening issues, not of her choice). No the US isn't communist. But if we keep allowing the government to butt their heads and hands into EVERYTHING we do, guess what.. we might just end up in a communist country. I mean, the government has it's rights, but so do we. 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

Heather,The School Bus I was on was for Christmas Carolling to Nursing Home's through the school . I do however know for a fact ,they Did not have seat belt's on the bus i was on. I am unsure if this was a public city bus or not ,as this was for Chorus,but again this was during school hour's. 

Dianne --- 18 years ago -

While agree that this country does seem to be turning into somewhat of "Nanny State" I truly think we are a long way from communism! The very people that we elect as our senators, representatives, and congress are the ones that come up with a lot of these laws. They also are motivated to propose stuff based on what the people want. So if enough people want smoke free restaurants and sign petitions and write letters, then the elected officials tend to follow that. As far the EMS bill - well if on is tooo brain dead to pay it or broke (or without insurance) then it I reckon it falls on the tax payers to cover the bills. Yes there are instances in which a seat belt can do more harm than good - but studies show that seat belts save lives. I don't have a clue why there are not seat belts on school buses, perhaps enough letters will get them on there sooner or later. Perhaps it's a different safety issue. A huge lumbering school bus is a little safer than a small sports car in regards to crash impacts. 

ItsMe --- 18 years ago -

I am so glad to see someone else bring up the seat belt law...I hate it myself. I have seen and known people also that have had accidents and may have survived if they didnt have it on. I believe the children should wear them cause they dont know better and we dont want them bouncing around in the back seat possibly cause us to have a accident but adults should be able to choose. The smoking thing, yeah I originally started that forum so I will leave that one alone. I have gotten ambulance bills sent to me numerous times while living here and in Ky. When my son was born and had to be airlifted to a childrens hospital, yeah I got that bill too. The only bus I have EVER seen with seat belts is the one my son rides. and thats mainly cause they are gifted children on board and they require them to wear it but its special kinds of seats too... 

Dianne --- 18 years ago -

Ultimately, what we allow the state to do is governed by the social contract we, as citizens, make with each other and our government. Absolute government control over everyday existence is the hallmark of communist regimes. While the US and state governments tell us what we SHOULD do, we do not have to listen. It is about choices and consequences... No one is forcing you to wear a seat belt, but you get a ticket if you do. Taken further, why must we have insurance? Or a drivers license? No one FORCES you to have either of these to drive, but there are consequences if you do not have them. Should we not require these at all? How much are they really going to protect your life in the event of an accident, as say, a seatbelt? I think that we are getting communism and laws that we disagree with confused: communism's entire purpose is to create a classless society (which we clearly do not have). Unlike communist countries, if we don't like the laws we can petition for their removal and it actually works. Or the supreme court can overturn the law if it is deemed unconstitutional. For seatbelt safety stats: http://www.car-accidents.com/pages/seat_belts.html http://www.pp.okstate.edu/ehs/kopykit/SEATBELT.HTM 

Rhonda P --- 18 years ago -

As far the EMS bill - well if on is tooo brain dead to pay it or broke (or without insurance) then it I reckon it falls on the tax payers to cover the bills. This would be paid by the relatives if the person was brain dead. Again this would not fall upon the tax payer’s. They will always find a way that the tax payer's will not have to pay. As for the people we elect senators, representative’s and congress , we all have seen over time how this plays out when it comes to politics . "If you scratch my back, I will scratch yours". So the best interest of the people are not always a factor to them. And "IF" they did have seat belt's on the bus we were on . They did not address the issue for everyone to put them on ,Not from the bus driver or the teacher .I was sitting in the front seat next to the teacher , so i would have heard it if they did state it . 

Dianne --- 18 years ago -

I am really not going to harp much further on the EMS bill, but I am pretty sure that's not on top of a dead person's list to pay for or even someone without insurance. Bottom line a lot of tax dollars go to paying for EMS and fire services for a variety of services, etc... Another reason why it is important to wear set belts while in a moving car is the person not wearing a set belt basically becomes a missile within the confides of the car. If a person in the back seat is the only one not wearing a seat belt, they have the opportunity to hit every person in the car and act as a 500 lb bowling ball. I have attached a link to a public service commercial that I saw when I got my driver license in the UK. They make the best reality commercials out there! If they advertised the same things here everyone would get the panties up in a twist about censorship and graphics! http://www.thinkroadsafety.gov.uk/campaigns/seatbelts/download/backwards.mpg 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
fort campbell
men
women

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day