Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: The horns of a dilemma

who's talking here?

~*Funky Munky*~ 1
*maranda* 1
✿~~Mabes~~✿ 2
Just Candy 1
Supervillain 2
*Amanda* 1
~⌘SNAFU⌘~ 1
SECURITY! 6
*CU Drama Queen* 1
who are you 1
Calypso 1
Odds 2
*Jessica* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: The horns of a dilemma

I don't think Tori is benefiting from public school anymore. When she was diagnosed, her doctors said there was a possibility that her rate of educational capacity would slow down considerably by the time she was 7 or 8. She's almost 9. I believe that she would benefit from one-on-one instruction and the only way that can be accomplished is through me. Now that the doctors have controlled my sleep problems, I can actually attempt it. I've looked at it through all angles and I can't see a downside to it. I'm sitting on the fence here and I want some votes from several different POVs. For those that don't know, Tori is moderate to severe autistic and her behavior problems are difficult to control for her teachers. Feel free to leave comments.

Do it. It's what's best. Vote
 
 95.2% (20)
Don't do it, and here's why. Vote
 
 4.8% (1)
Supervillain --- 17 years ago -

I don't think Tori is benefiting from public school anymore. When she was diagnosed, her doctors said there was a possibility that her rate of educational capacity would slow down considerably by the time she was 7 or 8. She's almost 9. I believe that she would benefit from one-on-one instruction and the only way that can be accomplished is through me. Now that the doctors have controlled my sleep problems, I can actually attempt it. I've looked at it through all angles and I can't see a downside to it. I'm sitting on the fence here and I want some votes from several different POVs. For those that don't know, Tori is moderate to severe autistic and her behavior problems are difficult to control for her teachers. Feel free to leave comments. 

*Amanda* --- 17 years ago -

Both of my best friends children are autistic. Her son is severe and her daughter is mild. She really struggles to find services that help her son. He was going to school, but it was more like daycare because the teachers couldn't spend the one on one time it takes to teach him something. She works with him constantly at home and has helped him to learn everything he knows. If you have the patience and the know how I say you should do it. It sounds like that is whats best for your daughter and I think you sound like a great mom. She is lucky to have a parent that cares as much as you do. 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

You know Ive always been telling you if you feel its right for her, and it would benefit Tori then do it 

*maranda* --- 17 years ago -

It is the best option when you are in the military and can't afford the special schools with one on one teachers. I will be home schooling my 10 yr old son next year if they don't give him the one on one teaching that they promised him at Wassom. I home schooled my little sister up to the 7th grade. It is not very hard if you take the time and energy it requires. I believe that you love Tori enough to do it, so go for it. 

*Jessica* --- 17 years ago -

I would do it. Simply because I feel that public school is failing my "normal" kids. I can imagine how your daughter is probably slipping through the cracks at public school with people who are only briefly trained on how to help her. I think that mama knows best and the fact that you even consider homeschooling an option shows that you have the compassion and understanding to go forth with it. My only concern would be socialization. I know autistic children are generally not social, but I still think it is important for them to be in social situations and environments. Can you get her involved in a club or group of some sort to maintain her social interactions? 

✿~~Mabes~~✿ --- 17 years ago -

Ive seen you interact with Tori and i think she would be better off learning with you, and she would learn more 

~⌘SNAFU⌘~ --- 17 years ago -

I'd give it a try...homeschooling I'd think would be tough and personally, I wouldn't trust myself enough to fulfill every aspect of a proper education. However, you have massive intelligence, Amber, and I think you'd rock with it. However, I'd also look into all of the other options too. For a backup plan, you know, not saying you will fail, but just to take some stress off of you, so you don't feel like you are the ONLY option. 

Calypso --- 17 years ago -

When it all comes down to it. You are her Mother, and you know what's best for her. If she's not benefiting from public schooling, try homeschooling. But just be sure you don't get too biased, and if she doesn't benefit from homeschooling, then you need to find an alternative to that too. 

Odds --- 17 years ago -

Try it for a year and see how well she progresses. I would't recommend homeschooling for everyone, it has it's ups and downs, but I believe that in this case, your daughter would probably learn more and I also believe that you have the intelligence to handle it. (Hey, not everyone does these days.) Anyway, if it were me, I would do it if I felt there was a strong possibility that my child would show more progress, but I would make the first year the "trial run". 

SECURITY! --- 17 years ago -

i When it all comes down to it. You are her Mother, and you know what's best for her. If she's not benefiting from public schooling, try homeschooling. But just be sure you don't get too biased, and if she doesn't benefit from homeschooling, then you need to find an alternative to that too. amen... 

SECURITY! --- 17 years ago -

after knowing you however for so long, i think it would be detrimental for speees. the reason being is big sister goes to school now, and its great for her, take her out and spees gonna want to start stayin t home as well. i knows my smee. 

SECURITY! --- 17 years ago -

an yes of course i have to be diffrent. 

who are you --- 17 years ago -

There was an autistic boy in my sons class last year and honestly I don't think the teachers took the time to sit with him and do the work. She treated him like any other child which is ok to in some situations. If that was my son I would have pulled him out and done it at home. It can not hurt to try it and see how well it goes. 

SECURITY! --- 17 years ago -

If that was my son I would have pulled him out and done it at home. It can not hurt to try it and see how well it goes. no but it can hurt the other child. her youngest looks up to her sister, so i think it would be bad. 

Odds --- 17 years ago -

I can understand Jen's point about it affecting the younger sibling. I believe this is a call that only Amber can make, as she knows her children better than anyone else. I think that if the situation were handled in a delicate way (the approach depending on your children specifically, only you can know the answer to this) it would not affect the other sibling, but ultimately the most important issue at hand is what the proper education for her oldest should be and which situation will suit her better for the long run. 

~*Funky Munky*~ --- 17 years ago -

I have researched and deeply considered homeschooling for my son before he started school. Many of my expectations have been failed thus far. Homeschooling a child is really not that difficult, so far I am getting that it's so much more beneficial and easier than dealing with the school system. Especially when you are an education advocate. By the time you figure in what you are already studying with your child and what time they want to do extra things, like read and play learning games.... they have had one-on-one and hands on instruction for 4 hrs straight or more. The minimum is 4 hours. But the universal home school site will tell you state requirements. Also there are many different programs. Since your daughter has Autism, there may be groups available, for her to get the social time she needs. As far as your other daughter is concerned. (I understand the need to try and keep things even between the two.) Personally I would address it as each of them having unique needs. Here are some links to get you started in case you do not have them. Home School Laws by state Home school resource 

Supervillain --- 17 years ago -

Jen, I thought it through completely as far as Spee is concerned. She's a social butterfly and I think taking her out of school and away from her friends to sit in the house with her sister and I would be doing her a disservice. She seems to be doing well in school so far, so why mess up a good thing? She ain't the squeaky wheel. I wish DoDEA didn't see the need to issue report cards for sped kids if they're holding them to a normal kids' standards. Based on that knowledge, Tori is a D-F student. Lovely. It doesn't matter the circumstances, that's just how they do it and every time I see it, it kills me. We had their conferences today. Like I said, Spee is doing very well. In the areas she needs help with, I can easily guide her now that I know what the teacher's expectations are. Her reading is two grades above her and her handwriting is tidier than most of her class. After having already attended Tori's conference, this put me in a good mood. Tori's conference was some more of the same. She's still tantruming and disrupting everything. Why? Because the fucking school system can't see fit to assign her ONE aide. No, they keep rotating and swapping out aids so that by the time Tori gets used to one, another one has to take over. Her teacher seems so overworked from trying to deal with her behavior problems and there is only so much the school will let me do to help. And before anyone offers well-meaning advice; I've already tried everything. Hence the homeschooling route. From what I've gathered it will take a bit of time to get established and for me to research it, but it's looking like a better solution all the time. Of course, my mother, one of the few opinions I actually value, is completely against this all. I had hoped that I'd be able to use the results of this poll to sway her, and I just wasted my breath. That woman is getting old and more set in her ways. Old people are fucking annoying. 

SECURITY! --- 17 years ago -

also tori needs interaction with other kids. all kids need that. i say give it another 6 week long period. this is their first 6 weeks, and tori needs to adjust. listen to your mother she knows you the best. 

Just Candy --- 17 years ago -

I know a lady who home schools her daughter spends like two days a week with other home schooled kids at one of these little centers on base. They get together so the kids get to socialize, plus they do lots of events together to try to close that gap on socializing 

SECURITY! --- 17 years ago -

LISTEN TO YOUR MOTHER..(IN DARTH VADARS VOICE) 

✿~~Mabes~~✿ --- 17 years ago -

After talking to Jen yesterday about this it got me thinking a lot more and has me in the middle. I seriously would let her in school a little bit longer, giving her a bit more time to adjust might help, maybe even changing teachers, maybe you could sit down with the principal and see if there is anyone specialized with more experience than the teacher she has now and Tori might be able to join her/his class. Jen also got me thinking about the Spee situation, it probably would happen that Spee after seeing that Tori gets to stay home and do different things than she does in school, would want to stay home too, then you would have to deal with that also besides home schooling Tori. About the whole home schooling and interacting with other kids thing : I met a Lady here who home schools her kids, and she explained me how it works and it honestly sounds like the got more interaction than kids that go to schools. I guess it really would depend on how much YOU want to interact lol So all in one like everyone has said it is up to you guys and sadly no one can take that decision from you guys. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day