Campbell Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Campbell community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Campbell bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Fort Campbell courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What would you do?

who's talking here?

~*Funky Munky*~ 2
Baroness 1
JustMandy 1
✿~~Mabes~~✿ 1
Swiper the Fox. 1
Supervillain 2
JMunderscore 3
brookee 3
*CU Drama Queen* 2
King Kong on Cocaine 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

brookee --- 17 years ago -

My neice came out of school (pre-K, ages 5-6) crying. Her mom asked her what was wrong and she told her that they had been keeping chicken eggs in an incubator. Well all but two of the eggs hatched, so they busted open the two that didn't hatch. The teacher asked them to look at the dead chicks then go to the "birth chart" and point to the stage of growth the chicks died. My neice is really upset about it. My sister doesn't know if she should say anything to the teacher or not, and my BIL (the dad) just tried to make it into something positive by telling my neice that atleast six hatched and so on. I think that it was a little inappropriate and my sister should talk to the teacher. What would you do? 

Supervillain --- 17 years ago -

My youngest is sensitive like that. I would call and complain. Hell, I'd have a problem seeing that sh1t, too. 

JustMandy --- 17 years ago -

UHHHH YEA I WOULD CALL THE SCHOOL I THINK ITS TO EARLY TO INTRODUCE THINGS LIKE THAT TO A 5 YEAR OLD. MAYBE LIKE 5 OR 6 GRADE.. 

brookee --- 17 years ago -

Thank you. My sister didn't want to over react. 

JMunderscore --- 17 years ago -

I think at that sensitive age it is inappropriate. If it was like the 5th or 6th grade then they'd be good to go but not with the young ones 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

Yea Id say something. Exposing small children to face death like that isnt right, especially since theyre so sensitive at that age 

~*Funky Munky*~ --- 17 years ago -

I honestly don't think it's inappropriate. Kids can not learn if they are sheltered. 

JMunderscore --- 17 years ago -

UHHHH YEA I WOULD CALL THE SCHOOL I THINK ITS TO EARLY TO INTRODUCE THINGS LIKE THAT TO A 5 YEAR OLD. MAYBE LIKE 5 OR 6 GRADE.. Ha ah I didn't even see your comment when I typed mine 

~*Funky Munky*~ --- 17 years ago -

Kids start understanding what death is before even age 5. When they have that ability, it's really up to parents to explain it more in depth. 

JMunderscore --- 17 years ago -

I honestly don't think it's inappropriate. Kids can not learn if they are sheltered. There is a certain appropriate age range which they should learn things at though. You aren;t going to teach a 1st grader sex ed are you? Same concept 

*CU Drama Queen* --- 17 years ago -

Kids start understanding what death is before even age 5. When they have that ability, it's really up to parents to explain it more in depth. Exactly. Hot topics like that should be left up to the parents in my opinion. They know how their kids can handle a sensitive situation and topic like that better than a teacher could understand 

Supervillain --- 17 years ago -

If it was just the one dead chick, I'd say okay. Big deal. But there were some live ones, all fluffy and cute...and then there are DEAD ones that will never chirp or even breathe. Kids don't need to make such harsh comparisons that early. They can't truly understand why some died and some didn't. Not at the age of 5. 

King Kong on Cocaine --- 17 years ago -

I wouldn't want my children to see that period. That's not a lesson that should be taught at that age. 

brookee --- 17 years ago -

When they have that ability, it's really up to parents to explain it more in depth. Exactly. Hot topics like that should be left up to the parents in my opinion. They know how their kids can handle a sensitive situation and topic like that better than a teacher could understand My neice doesn't take kindly to talk of death. She lost her grandma Loraine when she was 3 and her Uncle when she was 4. Both times she went into crazy mode and wouldn't let anyone close family out of her site because she thought the angels would take them away. I think the teacher could have let the parents know what she planned on doing so that the parents could chose if the child needed to be there for it or not. 

Baroness --- 17 years ago -

i guess since i grew up on a dairy farm every summer i don't see the big deal but that is just me 

✿~~Mabes~~✿ --- 17 years ago -

wow, i think if my daughter would come home telling me that i would probably already have the phone in hand to make an app with the teacher and principal about 3 min later lol. I dont think its the teachers place to explain death to children at that young age, like amber said, there is the cute fluffy ones alive and then the dead ones which hell thats wrong for a 5 yeat old to be tought by someone else then a parent or even a grandparent maybe . At least at that age, i wouldnt do it unless she really needed to know, like an animal of hers died or so, but its the comparing what i find really unapropiate. 

Swiper the Fox. --- 17 years ago -

To me that sounds like a horror movie.My 10 years old can't deal with death,we had a bunny that die a few months ago and she cry for a week.That's not a way to teach kids.It can traumatize them at such a young age.That's so sad.Sometimes I hate sending my daugther to school. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Campbell Underground

Swap ideas day